Two rules

A comparison of the two rules. The book looks at past prices.
Same amount each timeValue averaging
Fixed in advanceThe amount you put in. It can grow over time.What the account should be worth at each step
What the purchase depends onThe calendar onlyThe gap between the amount you need this month and what the shares are worth now
SalesThe rule itself does not sellIf the account is worth more than it should be, the rule says to sell. You can skip that
In the bookChapter 4, pp. 83–85Chapter 5, pp. 97–99

How the same-amount purchase is found

Shares you already hold are valued at the end as if they grew at the percent you entered. Whatever is still missing has to come from new purchases. The first purchase is solved so the series covers that gap. Each later payment is a bit larger if you allowed growth.

The future value of the series is the first purchase times ((1 + share growth) to the power of the months, minus (1 + payment growth) to the same power), divided by the difference between those two percents. If the percents are equal, that line would divide by zero, so the value it approaches when the percents are almost equal is used instead.

How the value plan is found

The amount you set aside this month reaches the next amount you need, if the shares grew by exactly the percent you entered. If the market did something else, the purchase is different and the gap stays in the reserve. The reserve is cash kept beside the account, not in shares. The plan itself is described on its own page. The amount you need does not rise in equal steps. The notation is on the formula page.

What changes in practice

With dollar-cost averaging the payment is known ahead of time. With value averaging it moves: each month it closes the gap between the amount you need and what the shares are worth. The book keeps a separate cash account for that gap. If the account is worth more than it should be, the rule says to sell. The same plan can be run without a sale: a purchase does not go below zero, the shares stay, and the difference sits in the reserve. That mode is described on its own page.

The calculator draws both rules side by side.

The chart on the calculator

The codes in the form are there so there is a price to use. A picture of price jumps is on the method page: that picture is about how wide the growth can be.

The chart shows money per month, not what the account is worth. The solid black line is how much to set aside. The orange dash is the same-amount purchase. The blue line with diamonds is the purchase or sale if the price follows More settings. If you left that as it is, the price stays the same.

Calculate both ways